The Golden Troll Awards
According to UrbanDictionary, a “troll” is:
One who posts a deliberately provocative message to a newsgroup or message board with the intention of causing maximum disruption and argument.
That’s the first entry. Most of them are something along the same lines, but if you only scroll down to number six, you’ll pick up this nugget:
One of many unsung internet heroes who are almost entirely misunderstood. Contrary to popular belief, many trolls are actually quite intelligent. Their habitual attacks on forums is usually a result of their awareness of the pretentiousness and excessive self-importance of many forum enthusiasts. As much as people may hate trolls, they are highly effective – their actions bring much of the stupidity of other forum users out into the great wide open.
Both definitions are most certainly valid. But it’s the second one that I find more truth in. These days, it seems like just about everybody needs to get trolled once in a while to keep them in line. And like most things that seem to Internet-only phenomena, trolling can spread into real life. And boy, was 2009 a good year for trolls. That’s why I want to recognize some of my favorites from the past year.

The Balloon Boy Family: Sure, we know the aftermath. The kid’s father, Richard Heene, was just sentenced to 90 days in prison. But for one wonderful afternoon, the country could remember a simpler time when kids could fall down a well or something like that and lie about it for attention (like Bart Simpson did). Give them credit for saying they sent the kid up in a hot-air Jiffy Pop balloon. Let’s see Sting get ‘em outta that one.
Michaele and Tareq Salahi: AKA the White House Gate Crashers. Another couple of attention-seekers, these two trolled their way to the top. Not only did they get to rub some elbows and shake some hands (one of which belonged to the president, I believe), they exposed the fact that even the Secret Service has become just as inept most other government agencies. And that’s scary.
Mark Teixeira and Nick Swisher: Tex gets on the list for telling the Red Sox that he’d join them, only to turn right around at the last second and sign with the Yankees instead. Sox supporting colleagues gave me the stink eye all year long, never with more vitriol than after the Yanks took the World Series in November. Feels good, man. As for Swish, the dude was obviously in the wrong place all season. Nobody, not even Johnny Damon, caught onto the fact that this guy should have played for the Red Sox in another life. He’s a full-blooded “idiot” if I ever saw one, and just knowing that his switch-hitting, relief-pitching visage is in pinstripes only makes it sweeter.
Mahmoud Amadinejad: As long as this guy remains in power in Iran, he’s trolling it up. And he’s not one of the good ones. Election protests? No problem. Round them up, arrest them, shoot them, whatever, just as long as it shuts up the opposition. Holocaust? What Holocaust? Oh, and the whole nuclear power program has nothing to do with building missles, even though I really want to blow up Israel.
James Cameron: Avatar is probably the best example of the long con that I can come up with. For years, geeks like myself had been reading all about The King of the World’s glorious return to science fiction after spending years underwater taking pictures of jellyfish. When he came back up, he announced that he’d be making Avatar with all sorts of new CGI, mo-cap, and camera technology in order to create a hyper-realistic movie experience. The rumor mill was going crazy, saying that the film was going to be revolutionary and that the story would be beyond epic. And then the trailer hit the Internet, and all of geekdom reacted with a unanimous, “Meh.” Remember the last time a visionary director said he’d wait years until the special effects were good enough to produce his magnum opus? Yeah, thanks, Mr. Lucas for those prequels.
Had our hopes been built up too much by all the hype? No. Not this time. You can get out-hyped by Transformers 2. You can’t get out-hyped by being told one thing and given another. This didn’t look like something I’d never seen before. It looked like a video game. It’s a cliche, I know, but it’s true. Then again, I still haven’t seen it (probably tomorrow afternoon, incidentally). But I’m nowhere near as pumped. If I still was, I’d have seen it already.
Barack Obama: You know, I’d give the president the number one spot, but you have to look at it like this: he’s nowhere near done. It’s like when the Lord of the Rings trilogy was coming out. The Academy didn’t give Peter Jackson the Oscar for The Fellowship of the Ring or The Two Towers. That’s because they all knew that The Return of the King was coming. They’d shower him with little naked golden men when the story was over. It’s the same here. And boy oh boy, if this is where we are after just one year, you can only imagine what the next three can bring.
And the winner of the 2009 Golden Troll Award:

Lady Gaga: Yeah. Lady Gaga. There, I said it. That’s one reason she’s my Number One. She made people have to say the words “Lady Gaga” with a straight face. Why? Because she sold records. Tons of ‘em. And the music is terrible. It’s like the second coming of Italo Disco. Plus, those ridiculous outfits. It’s beyond Bowie or Madonna when they hit the scene. She’s even been accused of being a hermaphrodite. And the kicker?
Her lyrics are fantastic. Being a person with working ears, I am subjected to hearing these songs all the time. And after hearing “Poker Face,” “Just Dance,” “Paparazzi,” and “Bad Romance” as many times as I have, beneath that mind-rotting beat, there are plenty of lyrical gems. I won’t get into it, but if you can stomach such aural torture, you can’t help but notice that she can write a good song. Yeah, she writes the words. That makes her legitimate. I can only hope that she picks up a producer who knows what “melody” is so that I don’t want to shove sharpened pencils into my ears.
So good on you, Stefani Germanotta of Yonkers, NY. You are the Golden Troll of 2009. Take a bow.

You should have seen that coming.


